I shouldn’t be doing this as I suspect I’ll just get myself into trouble again. Just like last time. But sometimes you just have to stand up and join the debate.
Exactly a month ago I wrote a piece entitled ‘Scary People‘. You don’t need to read it but it might help. It attracted around 37 comments and then, as always happens, it gets buried deeper into the stack and finally forgotten. And then up pops a new comment from someone calling themselves CarpetGuy (who is a first time commenter on this site) which I reproduce here:
When I first started reading this post, I was a bit offended, but as I read on, through the comments that followed, I could see that things here are as they are everywhere, a bit confused. Sarah Palin never got any orders from God, she simply prayed that what was happening was God’s will, as we all should. I am an American, but lived in Germany for more than a decade and my daughter is a citizen there. As for the reason of fearing Barack Obama, as an American it is simple, here in America, we DO NOT want to be a socialist society as in Europe. I know, as a European, you cannot understand this, but that is because you have never known the true Freedom of Capitalism in it’s purest form. No offense intended, it is just different here. Barack Obama represents everything that a true “Capitalist American” hates, as in Welfare and such. I know, it sounds crazy, but we believe that the people are in charge, not the government. We just want to be left alone, no taxes, no welfare, no social programs, simple right? The problem is that many Americans do not want to work, and want the government to send them a check, and that is what Barack Obama represents.
This is a clear, concise comment written, no doubt, from the heart and could probably have only been written by a true, patriotic American citizen. I have no real problem with patriotic Americans but I do have problems with historical inaccuracy and that overwhelming American belief that they all know how the rest of the world works. But let’s get Sarah Palin and God out of the way first:
Sarah Palin never got any orders from God, she simply prayed that what was happening was God’s will.
We are truly splitting the proverbial hair here. I did not say God ‘ordered’ her to do anything but if her statement that it was “God’s will” to build the new pipeline came through prayer then it seems to me she is making the statement that this is a project personally endorsed by her God. Actually, of course, as she resides and operates in a secular society where the separation of politics and religion is a constitutional directive one should question what God was doing advising her on a purely political decision in the first place. The woman just becomes scarier and scarier.
But on to the real issue here:
As for the reason of fearing Barack Obama, as an American it is simple, here in America, we DO NOT want to be a socialist society as in Europe. I know, as a European, you cannot understand this, but that is because you have never known the true Freedom of Capitalism in it’s purest form.
This truly is one of those marvellous statements that Americans of all persuasions come out with much of the time and, in my experience, have a rock-solid belief in. Let’s start with Capitalism, both in it’s ‘purest form’ and in it’s more modern form of a ‘mixed economy’. Capitalism, in it’s purest form, was not only a British doctrine but flourished here for a good 350 years much to the detriment of the vast majority of our citizens. On one side of the coin it created a huge Empire and kick-started the Industrial Revolution (both for good or bad). On the other side of the coin it also delivered America’s ‘Great Depression’ and notwithstanding the current markedly ’socialist’ activities of the current Republican administration, may well usher in another one. Unbridled Capitalism is like unleashing a rabid wolf into a dog pound.
Socialism, in it’s purest form, has never really been practised in European countries although we have all dallied with it and tried it on for size. What we have here is a watered down variant that is getting less and less support as time goes by. But it came about as a direct reaction to the long period of Capitalism that went unchecked for such a long time.
I may not personally agree with the policies of our more recent governments and I am the first to state that we are over-regulated and that government gets involved too much where it does not belong but I much prefer the compassion we show for the under-privileged and for those less able to compete for their daily meal.
The problem is that many Americans do not want to work, and want the government to send them a check, and that is what Barack Obama represents.
You heard it here first folks – Barack Obama wants to send all lazy Americans government checks. Which, of course, he doesn’t. Any more than any world government does. Any more than any working citizen of any nation does. Apart from those on the receiving end, nobody can actively want to see their hard earned tax money get spread around like this. This has nothing whatsoever to do with Socialism and probably has more to do with the Capitalist way of disenfranchising people. It is most certainly a symptom of a society with problems. But the notion that any politician actively supports such behaviour is quite obviously ludicrous. Britain’s most recent right wing government was unable to solve a problem it loathed in it’s 18 years of tenure as has the current right wing American administration. Perhaps this is because to a certain extent it is not quite so easy as it sounds.
In pure Capitalism, the small few get educated, can look after their health, can own property and ride roughshod over the majority who remain doomed by the circumstance of their birth. In pure Socialism the incentives, challenges and goals that people need are removed. Neither doctrine can work without seriously diminishing the growth and progress of a nation. The world saw this clearly in the downfall of the Soviet Union and the legacy that was left behind. CarpetGuy predictably sees this event as the direct result of US policy – whether of the late President Reagan by negotiation or – as he would have it – the sheer dominance of American armed forces firepower. Indeed it seems to have become part of the American collective myth that they alone were responsible for the breakup. It wasn’t, of course, the primary reason, although it may have helped a little. The Soviet era finally unravelled because the will of the people made it happen. It is what eventually happens to all extremes of political doctrines imposed by the few on their nation. The nations with stability and longevity steer a course somewhere between extremes and accept that to have the good bits, you need to deal with the bad as well.